Screenindia : Screen Latest News
PopularNews
Most Emailed Articles
Most Read Articles

When Resul Pookutty almost walked out of Slumdog

-A +A
Font
Shaju Philip and Alaka Sahani Posted: Feb 23, 2009 at 1949 hrs IST
Slumdog millionaire
Resul Pookutty almost made the biggest mistake of his life during the making of Slumdog Millionaire. The sound mixer, who picked up an Academy Award for Best Sound Mixing at Los Angeles's Kodak Theatre on Monday, felt the Slumdog team wasn't giving sound its due importance. After a heated exchange with Danny Boyle, Pookutty walked out of the film, only to be wooed back by the filmmaker.

Just before he left for foreign shores, to pick up the trophies from the BAFTA and Cinema Audio Society (CAS) award and now the Oscar, Pookutty said: "I would have been crying now had I not been persuaded to join the project back."

"It was a difficult project and Danny was very demanding. It put a lot of strain on me emotionally and physically," Pookutty recalled. Since the film was shot in Mumbai, a "very noisy city", in motion, the sound designer had trouble recording the sound from the viewers' perception. In keeping with the film's flavour, Pookutty decided to record the soundscape of the city.

The sequences shot at the Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus were among the toughest. "Since I wanted to record the sound of city life, I positioned my assistants with mikes across the station," he said.

In fact, after a career spanning 13 years in the industry, 36-year-old Pookutty applied fresh tactics for this film. "I had to constantly reinvent ways of getting the best possible sound," he revealed.

But then, just like Jamal in Slumdog Millionaire, perseverance has been the story of Pookutty's life. He was the youngest of eight children born to an impoverished family in a non-descript Kerala village, Vilakkupara, 80 km from Thiruvananathapuram. His father was a private ticket bus examiner, and he learnt to study in the light of the kerosene lamp as their village had no electricity.

Cinema was far from mind, and Pookutty tried his hands at many things before straying into the world of celluloid. He reared domestic animals, sold milk, later took tuitions to finance college.

For a brief while, he dreamt of becoming a doctor, but gave it up when he failed the medical entrance. After graduation in Physics, he joined the Law College, Thiruvananthapuram.

However, even then, say acquaintances, sounds seemed to hold a strong fascination. "During a recent reception at the village, Resul said the chirping of birds and gurgling of the rivulet had always evoked much curiosity in him," said his brother Baiju.

It was only out of curiosity and peer pressure that he applied for the sound engineering course at the Pune Film and Television Institute of India (FTII). He failed the first time, returned to Thiruvananthapuram, and read up all the books he could find on sound engineering. In the next entrance examination and group discussion, Pookutty passed.

While there has been no looking back, in home state Kerala, it is only recently that people came to know Pookutty, who has been living in Mumbai with his wife Shadiya and two children for the past decade. "Even the people of Vilakkupara learned about the feat of its son only recently," said Baiju.

However, in the run-up to the Oscars, all that changed. Monday evening saw the entire village glued to television to watch the Oscars. As Pookutty's name was read out, the crowd was ecstatic. Many could not stop their tears and ran to kiss the screen. There were impromptu processions on the streets, many carried banners.

"After the results were out, Resul called me," says Baiju. "But emotionally choked, he could not speak." His regret remains that his parents, who are dead, couldn't see their son go so far.

Like most, Pookutty said he didn't have much inkling Slumdog Millionaire would go on to become such a phenomenon, though he was a fan of Boyle. "I even had a poster of Trainspotting in my room at FTII," he said.

When he first met Boyle, Pookutty added, he was tongue-tied when the British director asked him to suggest some films he should watch to know about his sound designing style. He replied, "Watch any of my films, you will find my mark." When he met Boyle for the second time, Pookutty said, he found that the director had done his homework.

Resul Pookutty dedicates Oscar to India

Sound engineer Resul Pookutty became the third Indian to bring Oscar glory for India by winning the award for sound mixing in ‘Slumdog Millionaire’ here today.

"I dedicate this award to my country. This is not just a sound award but a piece of history that has been handed over to me," a beaming and emotional Pookutty said while dedicating the trophy to a billion Indians.

"I come from a country and civilisation that gave the world the word that precedes silence and is followed by more silence. That word is 'Om'. So I dedicate this award to my country," said Kerala-born sound technician.

Pookutty shared the honours with colleagues Ian Tapp and Richard Pryke.

"This is unbelievable. I share the stage with two magicians, who captured the noise and cacophony of Mumbai to create the soul stirring artful sound of 'Slumdog Millionaire'," he said.

Pookutty has won a BAFTA and a more recent Cinema Audio Society (CAS) awards for best sound mixing. He is the first Indian to win the CAS award.

PostComments
Post Comments
Name * Message *
Email ID *
Subject *
TERMS OF USE: The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.
ViewComments
this mind set by raj on 2009-03-01 19:32:30.896509+05:30 we all know how much ur petriotic..most my muslim friends are fan of azar ,akram,huk imran khan etc..but no one likes sachin ???they all supported indai wen azar was captain ..after that they are now only supprting pathan brothers..no sehwag or sachin..this is ur mind set...but no other relegion is like that way..same way with me.. i like sachin,ponting ,hussey etc..but no waqar or azar.....this is our miind set..its difficult to chage..so u support ur people and let us support our own..dnt play some patriotic drama here...

Reply | Forward

1 And the Oscar goes to.... Psuedo-religious Fanatics
by Rahanash on 2009-05-21 11:47:33.106334+05:30I am deeply hurt by some of the comments by fellow citizens. Where are we heading to? I am an indian and a very proud one too... the fact that i am a muslim has nothing to do with the love i have for my country. I was excited when Shashi Tharoor was nominated to the post of UN Chief, I felt proud when Vikram Pandit took over as head of Citibank... I never looked at the fact these where non-muslims... they are all indians making our country proud.It's a shame we bring religion out of the temples, mosques and churches in to everything that is remotely religious.Let the Gods be left alone in peace where they belong... My grand parents fought for the freedom of this land and now my patriotic feelings are being challenged.Jai Hind.

Reply | Forward

oscar by sunil on 2009-02-25 01:03:59.774888+05:30 my dearest celebrity.i m proud of u man.

Reply | Forward

We are oroud of you by anand on 2009-02-24 15:42:42.873109+05:30 Its refreshing to see people like you Resul...Hats off to you and we all indians are proud of you

Reply | Forward

Be Indian by INDIAN on 2009-02-24 12:57:32.253135+05:30 SHAME ON YOU STUPID PEOPLE WHO IS SPREADING FUNDEMENTALISM HERE.Congrats the people who bags the Oscar.

Reply | Forward

the real OSCAR winner by sudheesh kg on 2009-02-24 10:55:02.554983+05:30 we all congratulate you on the effort you took for achieving this real award on 2009. may GOD bless you again with this kind of boon to you and all the indians.

Reply | Forward

When Resul Pookutty almost walked out of Slumdog by Aftab Shibli Fatmi on 2009-02-24 09:44:16.737893+05:30 It is disgusting to see prople showering linking patritism whenever a muslim earn laurels for the country. We saw in case of Kalam saheb and now in case of the heroes of Oscar award. No one gives the certificate of patrotism to Gulzar saheb. It only reflects the poor mindset of those who are distributing the certificates that they see muslims as non patriotic. This is a very sad state of affairs. Please stop doing so as it hurts the muslims. We Indian muslims do not need any certificate from any one to prove our credential. There are lumpen elements in the society and they belong to different religious belief including Islam. Their act should not be associated with the religion that they claim to follow.I congratulate all the Indian artists who made this film successful and contributed in winning the Oscar award.

Reply | Forward

Resul Pookutty by Aftab on 2009-02-24 09:19:32.688698+05:30 What a shame. No body says that Gulzar you are true Indian. Why people utter this word in case of muslims? Who are these people who are distributing certificates of patritism to only muslims? Please open your mind and heart. This country belongs to one and all and muslims are not required to have your certificate to proove that they are good Indians.

Reply | Forward

1 Certified Indians.
by Hassan on 2009-02-24 15:45:56.045584+05:30Today only the people of the ideology which killed our father of nation and tried to sabotage our fredom movement are questioning Indian Muslims who shed their blod for this country's freedom....who stood back in the country during the partition.Because they loved their motherland.Funny is tha these groups couldn't produce even a single freedom fighter except Desh Drohis sofar...the price of freedom was not so cheap as these goons presume.

Reply | Forward

1 Patriotism
by Nid on 2009-02-26 20:16:25.174111+05:30DO you know 95% of muslims voted for the creation of Paksitan, but only 15% migrated?That is because people were too poor to migrate, only the rich from India and some in the north were able to migrate to Pakistan.Anyway, thats not the question now, 95% of muslims in India were born in India and if some of them are not patriotic, well, its just their loss :)

Reply | Forward

rasul pookutty"s oscar by saheer sha on 2009-02-24 08:07:54.649501+05:30 we saw result of your hard work ,all indians are waiting Your next film, god bless you

Reply | Forward

TRUE INDIAN... by RAJESH on 2009-02-24 07:44:25.837519+05:30 AFTER ALL STILL "BHARAT' REMAINS. HEART FELT CONGRATS MR. RESUL POOKUTTY...YOU ARE THE TRUE INDIAN. "OM" AND INDIAN CULTURE IS NO WAY CMPARABLE TO SEMITIC RELIGION CONCEPT AS MOST OF THE SO CALLED SECULARISTS BELIEVES.

Reply | Forward

Resul Pookutty by Najeeb on 2009-02-24 05:33:50.22993+05:30 Why not Advani, Modi, Sudershan and Ashok Singhal recite Kalima la ila ha ill Allah. Why you guys always want Indian muslim to adopt or say hindu scripts? If we say or read scriptures then only you consider as indians??? What a shame is this...every individual has a right to follow the truth path.

Reply | Forward

1 y not m fhussain
by raj on 2009-03-01 19:35:55.585963+05:30u people shouted against danish cartoonist, agaisnt taslima nasrin...same job was done by mf husain but agaisnt another relegion ...then y u not shouted against mf hussain ? y ur universities are giving award to him ? same way..every individual got right..

Reply | Forward

Well done Slumdog Millionaire! by Mariam Abuhaideri on 2009-02-24 05:09:06.763787+05:30 Congratulations...Yesterday you made history and today your fellow countrymen cannot be more proud! You and the team worked hard and today enjoy the fruits of your efforts!

Reply | Forward

Controversey is futile by Dee on 2009-02-24 04:48:19.438432+05:30 They have song 'Jai ho Jai ho' in the movie not 'Allah hu Allah hu', so I guess they do whatever is sellable. But surely a poor Muslim boy movie has market. Probably next year Oscars will go to movie based on Palestine where a kid will goto bomb schools in Israel or in Afghanistan or in Swat valley.

Reply | Forward

Slumdog by Hirsh on 2009-02-24 00:28:18.898992+05:30 I wonder if a Hindu like me would have had the guts or the knowledge to say what Pookutty said about Om. Muslims like him (and many Indian muslims are like him) are very precious.

Reply | Forward

Jai Ho ! Resul Pookutty by Bharat Sharma on 2009-02-23 21:33:28.238814+05:30 What a wonderful Human Being! I really liked his speech, keep up the good work. Bravo!

Reply | Forward

Congratulations by Sana on 2009-02-23 19:14:45.994921+05:30 Pookutty showed amazing character in dedicating his well earned award to the people of India. India should be so proud. He talked so well and he said coz, that is what people here in the west connect with India, and in today's world Om and Shanti means a lot. Everyone should want peace and silence in today's chaotic world. People do not make it political and about secularism, as this was meant to hurt nobody's feelings. We are all Indians and we should be proud of our technicians and composers and lyricists. We are not a bunch of idiots, we are talented, but we just need someone to harness it in a proper channel. Thanks to Swarup, Boyle, Gulzar, and Rahman too for putting India on the world map. Congratulations to all of you. Job well done!

Reply | Forward

1 Well said
by Ashraf Babu on 2009-02-24 12:40:17.845748+05:30Thanks for the message. this is what I am goint to say. These stupid people are searching bloddy fundementalism on each aspects..that's the fate of India.

Reply | Forward

The Religion of Humanity by A well Wisher on 2009-02-23 19:11:41.695321+05:30 Lets go beyond the man made barriers of religion, caste, creed. Skin Deep we are all the same. Most of us are taught that religion is a path of goodness but in most cases we cant choose the religion we want to practice for our own personal peace. The physical differences, the customs are enforced after we are born as a child, where we do not understand anything.....maturity dawns very late....I wish we grow to love and practice Humanity which is love, tolerance, sacrifice and the other good virtues which are the foundation stones of all religion. Men have corrupted what God made to bring peace and happiness. There are real issues which we need to together resolve to solve - poverty, education, employment, protect environment

Reply | Forward

congratulations by balachandran on 2009-02-23 17:35:43.405123+05:30 We are very proud of you, Resul. Congratulations. (Bobby's brother in law)

Reply | Forward

It is a culture Mohammed ! by Aniyan on 2009-02-23 16:37:43.189495+05:30 Kaayal Anbu raja Mohammed, it is nothing but Indian culture. Resul Pookutty is rightly conscious that his predecessors were not Muslims nor your's ! India is compressed with the adopted religions, reined in with promise of helps. How muslims are joining for the Satyanarayana pooja in Mumbai's building. It is a culture Mohammed; Just do not divide the society.

Reply | Forward

1 Imported Religion
by Rana Basheer on 2009-02-23 20:51:38.294401+05:30All religions are imported including Hinduism by Aryans. So lets not argue about that. Congrates to everyone who made India proud.

Reply | Forward

1 Imported Religion
by raj on 2009-03-12 15:31:31.741762+05:30I think Mr. baseer should comment on fact which either he doesnt know, or know to an extent of his favourism. Hinduism is never imported, read any history book, there is no Guru (like Mohammed sahab in case of Islam or Jeses for christian) of Hinduism. It is the religion just adopted by default by the ancient generation. With the course of time, as the evulution progressed, different religion started. Those who liked the new flavour; changed; those who didnt, they dint change. And for your kind information Aryan were nobody but Hindus.

Reply | Forward

2 We use OHM.. too.
by racnet on 2009-02-23 19:33:36.056773+05:30We Christians in kerala use Ohm.. shanti.. in some our meditations. It is something that lives in the every Indian mind since time immemorial, irrespective of what religious masks we wear..

Reply | Forward

Resul Pookutty wins Oscar by KRST on 2009-02-23 16:20:29.641749+05:30 A R Rehman we had always heard of but it is Resul Pookutty who really makes me proud. Shows to go that religion does not belong to anyone. This nation belongs to all. His dedicating his award to all Indians on Shivaratri and talking about the wonderful word 'Om' was heart-warming. This not to take anything away from Rehman who might have changed his religion but, I think, is no less a patriot than any other Indian. Congrats to both of them!

Reply | Forward

1 TALIBAN
by C.K.Sunil on 2009-02-23 18:09:08.312096+05:30You are a corrupt mind and more adaptable to Taliban ideology.

Reply | Forward

hyppocracy by Kaayal Anbu raja Mohamed on 2009-02-23 16:07:02.21591+05:30 So, to show our patriotness we indian muslims have to hang out our hearts in our shirts and shout from rooftops OM, then only you people will accept as indians!!!!!!!!!. What a hypocracy of thoughts? Shame on you for those comments.

Reply | Forward

oscar for rasul by randhir on 2009-02-23 15:47:28.243085+05:30 Josh, i read your comments. I salute you. u hav made the observation. Rasul is a gem , like a Taj, the symbol of Indianness.OM is for everyone who belives in this Indianness.What to say about Rehman, who had earlier silenced fanatics by chanting vande matram.I hope no mullah issue a fatwa against Rasul. We are all proud of you.

Reply | Forward

1 Comment about partition
by Mohammad AbdulWahab on 2009-03-01 20:46:08.481153+05:30Pse look the political History ofIndia,who is responsible for partition, Jinnah or the Congress party dominated by Nhehu,Why Jinnah left the Congress Party, some one give an answer.Thank you

Reply | Forward

Hats Off Pookutty by subburaj on 2009-02-23 15:44:15.200023+05:30 Hats off Resul Pookutty. You very deserve this award. Your paitriotism is amazing. I pray to Almighty God to bestow you many such laurels in the years to come.

Reply | Forward

Wonderful moment by Dilipkumar Nair on 2009-02-23 15:13:41.482246+05:30 Congrats Pookutty, Contrats!!!. Our heartiest felicitations for this wonderful occation, we salute you, for your dedication.

Reply | Forward

Oscar hype- its Hoax by voice on 2009-02-23 14:01:48.00681+05:30 This is a calculated ploy by the US using the Academy .US knows that the Osacars are viewed by the people world over and a good marketing too They need to bridge the gap with the Muslim world. The Story line is of a poor Muslim boy getting rich . and the awards are given to two Muslim artist . if you see the movie you will be convinced that the movie and the music is nothing but average .

Reply | Forward

1 I agree, neither deny
by aqmamin on 2009-02-23 15:24:11.774021+05:30neither I agree nor do I deny your observation, no one denies the fact that A.R.Rahman is a music genius in India, but it is almost impossible to understand the train of thoughts of americans in all all aspects of worldly, commercial, political and ethical life, they are capable of doing what you suspect they have done, probably your are right, probably you are wrong, in the past 10 years or so Indian women chosen as the world beauty queens belong to this category too, americans will go to any extent to fall in love with india to create new merceneraries to fight the american empire building, it is a pity that India has fallen into the trap of zionists, neocons and their bossom friends.

Reply | Forward

1 Oscar
by voice on 2009-02-23 16:59:06.019925+05:30I am not being fanatic as you think .You dont know how the Americal mind work .with the change in adminstration they need to bridge with the Muslim world and they have a right product in hand now .A filim portraying the resuregence of a Muslim youth and they have 2 muslim artists they can give the awards to .Do anybody sincerly think Slumdog Millionair worth these awards ,keeping aside the patriotic feeling . Can you explain why better indiam movies went to the Oscar did not get the award ?

Reply | Forward

2 Oscar
by M.kutty on 2009-02-23 14:33:46.238231+05:30This is a ridiculous observation of a religious fanatic. Hell

Reply | Forward

1 @voice
by Tejas on 2009-02-23 14:56:58.830001+05:30Ahhhh....the creative power of the fundamentalist mind, laughable yet worrying because these are supposedly educated people who spout such nonsense.

Reply | Forward

CONGRADULATION by ANEESH on 2009-02-23 13:56:45.065751+05:30 Congratulations Mr Resul !! You made us proud

Reply | Forward

Oscar by Parameswaran M.K. on 2009-02-23 13:51:46.327095+05:30 Congatulations Pookutty. We, all Indians, share this moment of enjoyment. Keep it up

Reply | Forward

Proud to be an Indian by Josh on 2009-02-23 13:12:20.893684+05:30 As an Indian Christian, I am proud to see Resul Pookutty, a Muslim, honouring the primordial Hindu syllable 'Om' in his Oscar acceptance speech. It was a defining moment and I hope more Indians transcend artificial boundaries of north/south caste/religion and bring more accolades to the motherland. Wish all an auspicious Mahashivrathri. Jai ho.

Reply | Forward

1 jai ho...............
by sudheesh kg on 2009-02-24 10:59:23.521006+05:30JAI HO...... AS YOU SAID A TIME MUST COME WHEN NOBODY BOTHERS FOR HINDU, CHRISTIAN OR MUSLIM......... JAI HO........ MR. JOSH

Reply | Forward

oscar by Neduncheziyan on 2009-02-23 13:02:26.350656+05:30 hey, pookutty, donot mix OM here

Reply | Forward

1 OM kya tere baap ka hai?
by Astrix91 on 2009-02-23 15:18:20.812573+05:30Don't be so cynical my friend, nobody has a copy right on OM thus anybdy can use it anywhere and in whichever way deems fit.

Reply | Forward

1 Ohm is from hinduism
by David on 2009-02-24 07:41:10.243756+05:30Thats crap. Om is by hindus, and has been, and still practiced by hindus. Keep your Amen to urself.

Reply | Forward

2 Nedunchezhiyan must be a atheist
by Mohan on 2009-02-23 17:59:18.178256+05:30Nedunchezhiyan must be a DMK supporter and thus a atheist. Any way hats off to Rasul. I am proud of him to have come out with the best lines. When one can become a nationalist above religion and caste, the country gains.About Rehman, I was sad he paid credit to his mother alone. He is married and definitly his wife also must be complimented for supporting his acitivities.

Reply | Forward

oscar by george on 2009-02-23 11:59:43.648268+05:30 Congratulations. Well deserved.Whatever you have achieved is because of you and not from any other source,definitely not religion. Unlike Rehman who changed his religion to show that one religion is better than the other. This only shows how poor his rest of the brain is. One day he will realise this.You will grow better and better and thanks for making our country proud.We salute you.

Reply | Forward

1 Oscar
by rajagopalan on 2009-02-23 21:06:41.2787+05:30George you are mistaken. Rehman changed his religion even before he became a music director. So his changing religion has no bearing on his performance as a music director. I am a Hindu but I am proud that AR Rehman won an Oscar, because I feel I am an Indian more than a Hindu and AR Rehman is also an Indian more than a muslim.

Reply | Forward

This is a reply!!! by Shone Mekkattu on 2009-02-23 11:49:18.421616+05:30 This is a reply to those Indians who still think that people from our villages can't compete with the world!!!Vandemataram...Congrats to Resul!!!U r a role model for all Indians!!!

Reply | Forward

Oscar speech by Hemant on 2009-02-23 11:48:47.374238+05:30 I confess, this is first time I am hearing Pookutty's name. I am not big on movies either but admire Pookutty's speech. Where many become speechless Pookutty remember his roots and put in very nice words. Nice to have country man like him, may be now I will follow his work more closely. Congrats and thanks for remembering every Indian at your moment of glory.Wish I colu

Reply | Forward

Congrats!! by John Thomas on 2009-02-23 11:36:36.714514+05:30 Congratulations Resul !! You made us proud.

Reply | Forward

1 Resul
by anon on 2009-02-24 11:31:30.792421+05:30I was happy to see Resul winning. I felt that he chose to share his happiness with everyone in the country. I dint care if he was a muslim or christian. Rehman chose his words very carefully. He dint make a single mention of the country or people. It is his choise. I dont see a reason why Indians should celebrate his success. He is religious fanatic and it was obvious in his speech.

Reply | Forward

Feel so great about Rassul by Manu on 2009-02-23 11:02:53.824263+05:30 I feel so proud of Rassul for his comments after the oscar!! He is great!! His dedication to the country is awesome. His comments on "Om" is also very true... I am afraid may be some mullahs will issue fatwa on him for chanting "Om" as its aginst Islam!!!!!!

Reply | Forward

1 Rassul you are great!
by AjitKumar on 2009-02-24 07:54:26.747421+05:30Mr.Manu,Very well said.I fully agree with everything you wrote.Rassul and Rehaman both are wonderful human beings.

Reply | Forward

2 What about other extremists...
by Bruce on 2009-02-23 17:20:22.588735+05:30Yeah..as if they have nothing else to do...come'on..If you look at it that way then even the fundamentalists from the other side of the spectrum must be fuming that a muslim has won an award...shut the crap. Let's just be proud as Indians and enjoy this moment.

Reply | Forward

Day of 'Om' - Shivarathry !! by K. P. Pillai on 2009-02-23 10:51:18.716625+05:30 Hearty Congratulations Pookutty !! Its a great achievement !! Lots of appreciation on an exceptional speech you made on this auspicious day of 'Om' - Shivarathry !. The Indians salute you.

Reply | Forward

Rasul by Sushand on 2009-02-23 10:51:16.454974+05:30 I salute this young man who dedicated the award to his country. His words will be quoted by many for the years to come.

Reply | Forward

Oscar reactions by Mala on 2009-02-23 10:30:24.111369+05:30 Some sentiments on "OM" and the billion Indians, probably in his finest hour

Reply | Forward

A Wonderful achievement for him and for India. by Varghese Joseph on 2009-02-23 10:27:13.396301+05:30 Congrats Resul Pookutty!!!. This is a moment of joy for every Indian citizens. Let us hope every citizens in India would share this moment of joy what you have brought in here to our country. May Almight Bless you. Hope you would do beautiful sound mixings in future.

Reply | Forward

Mumbai! by Varun on 2009-02-23 09:36:57.429565+05:30 Mumbai IS India's culture...and the BEST city in the world...these awards are a celebration of that!

Reply | Forward

1 Mumbai!
by Oracle Man on 2009-03-12 19:11:08.160634+05:30Chup rahega dhakkan, tere sahar ke slum k expose karke koi award utha raha hai aur tu BEST ke pichhe pada hua hai ..... nd Shut up.. mumbai is not at all India's culture.. India lives in it's villages... Just go to any village where farmer are committing suicide then you will come to know why Mumbai is not India's culture ..you crap ...

Reply | Forward

The Truth by Rony on 2009-02-23 09:13:39.508174+05:30 The movie is a hollywood movie..just because the guy is an indian it dosent mean that India has an oscar to their name..When India wins an oscar for "Best Foreign Movie", then and then only can the award be truly owned by india..

Reply | Forward

1 The Truth
by KVSKumar on 2009-02-23 10:19:21.78765+05:30Will you also say that only when a (wo)man grows grains and fetch water from his/her well and cooks it in a pot made by him/her using firewood from his/hre backyards and also prepares curry using massala grown hy him/her, then only we can call it homefood?

Reply | Forward

1 :-)
by jacob on 2009-02-25 14:22:07.765526+05:30well said

Reply | Forward

2 FANTASTIC FILM!
by A.Kader on 2009-02-23 10:06:29.749382+05:30I am happy Indians have won Oscars.It does not matter a foreigner made it.The talented Indians got fantastic opportunities with the film.Several thanks to Boyle for presenting the world the truth about India,i.e the poverty of the majority due to the cruel exploitation of the egoistic rich Indians.The slums are realities of our India several years after independence.Admitting the truth is the first step towards changes to uplift the poor.

Reply | Forward

Great by Avinash Baranwal on 2009-02-23 09:06:24.937617+05:30 Congrats...However, let us makes a movie which shows India's rich culture and richness and then win oscar for that.

Reply | Forward

1 India's rich culture means...
by krishna on 2009-02-23 09:58:45.758603+05:30Throwing stones at buses, bundhs, rasta roko's, riots and political murders, stalling parliament, is this we want to show? May be you should first see true India and ask the question whether we are preserving our old 'rich' culture or not.

Reply | Forward

1 Rich culture means something!
by David on 2009-02-24 07:44:31.863142+05:30And you think its the fault of the 'old' culture? It seems you base your education on the Idiot box...and you are one. Open your eyes and look around, that happens all over. You are a product of communism and you dont even know it. Do you think without numberals and zero the world would have progressed?

Reply | Forward