please don't talk when you don't know what to talk
by Harkawalpreet singh on 2009-07-31 15:53:34.695772+05:30 Sikh is made out of love, to love. Sikhism is not a caste but is the teaching in itself. those who are commenting here about sikhism does not know the ABC of sikhism. Just put in your head in yourself and see can you comment about such a thought . it is just like a frog commenting about the ocean. Those, who does not know the meaning of the of there names even, are commenting about such an ocean of thought. the thought which is brought by GURU NANAK. i dont know from where you all got the courage of commenting on religion and the religion which is SIKH. Please dont talk when you dont know what to talk. it can hurt somebody. It can give pain to somebody who is religious.
Reply | Forward
Don't talk when you don't know what to talk
by Harkawalpreet singh on 2009-07-31 15:38:46.626939+05:30 please dont talk if you dont know what to talk . Sikhism is not just a religion and these hair are not just hair . it is some what like your mother keeping in with your dad , Sikhism has come out of love , the love with the God and these things are not for stupids to under stand . just using your dirty and inhuman consiousness of your mind and brain to comment on the gift given to us by Guru . do you know he meaning of religion ? you are going towards the direction from where you have come from, today you are not getting any meaning of hair tomarrow you will not understand the meaning of the cloths you were and you will say not to were it , and you will start living without cloths and will say your mom dad and your sisters and brothers not to were them as they dont have any meaning . and sombody like you will say i feel too comfortable in not wearing cloths . so it is not like that some of the things are beyond your thoughts and dont try them . else i want to say many things but i cant say because one gets dirty when he plays with dirty people
Reply | Forward
Publicity
by Ashok on 2009-07-31 10:11:47.733145+05:30 Old dog's trick. Do something controversial, then apologize,in the process gain tons of publicity. Why does media fall for it? Big question,why does public? Why not avoid movies of actors who manipulate all the time?
Reply | Forward
Adapt to the changed realties or get extinct, painfully
by jas on 2009-07-31 09:34:39.379758+05:30 I wonder if these so called leaders of Sikhs have patents on the beard of all Sikhs and Sikh-looking people? I as a person who supported long hair for 27 years of his life, would like to suggest to all 'traditional Sikhs' to get their hair cut for once at least. If you don't like it then you can grow them back any time. Do this just to excercise your option as a free man. These so called symbols of Sikhism have become shakles that have been limiting our choices for no good reasons and are hampering the spread of Sikhism as a religion and philosophy. Believe me you come across as a bigoted man who is slave to religious customs and convetions. This prejudices most people's judgement of you even before you talk. And you know what people say about the first impression? Staying in military uniform prescribed centuries ago cannot serve any good purpose and it is not. I love to wear turban but I would not let anybody to make it must for me for religious reasons. You can have that choice too.
Reply | Forward
1 Adapt to change.........or extinct......
by Amarjeet on 2009-08-04 02:15:34.936067+05:30I appreciate your bold dialogue. We are slaves to religious customs and conventions, but not by choice. Power and position humgary religious heads wont let people come out of these premitive shackles, else they will lose all they got so cheap. Look at the politics prevelent at all religious places. God save Human Race!!!!!
Reply | Forward
leave the sikhs alone
by khalsa on 2009-07-31 08:47:47.131834+05:30 We are a minority but do not ask for reservations,show me a Sikh beggar,poverty is almost non-exist among us,We can take care of ourselves .Leave us alone,this message is for all especially the self appointed jathedars and filmwalas.REMEMBER 'NA HOTE GURU GOVIND SINGH THO SUNNAT[circumcission] HOTI SAB KI'
Reply | Forward
Hyper-sensitivity of religious idiots is even more sickening
by Jas on 2009-07-31 08:30:25.110351+05:30 People depicting Sikhs as jokers and bufoons and people telling sick jokes about Sikhs are disgustingly stupid people who try to be funny. I am eually disgusted by the Sikhs who have been defining Sikhs and Sikhism in ever increasingly narrower terms.These bigoted idiots have reduced the beautiful philosopy of Guru Nanak to some outward symbols of facial hairs and turbans only. Such people have monopolized the Gurdawras and would not allow other Sikhs who refuse to be defined by unshorn hairs to have any say in Sikh affairs. The fact that majority of their own sons are not keeping long hair and vast majority of their daughters do not want to marry 'tradition sikhs' does not seem to put some compromising sense in their stuborn and stupid heads. Instead these so called Sikh religious leaders and some political leaders also keep defining Sikhism like talibans are defining Islams. Why a little (or even for that matter lots) of romance can not happen in Gurdwara. Does God hates love so much
Reply | Forward
It needs courage to laugh on oneself.
by Iqbal Singh on 2009-07-31 04:39:15.795841+05:30 for God sake, we don't need fanatics in India,and as a sikh i want to tell these so called custodians of the path to open the eyes to our times and don't waste time on trivia. Please take it light heartdly, The Santa Banta jokes.
Reply | Forward
Saif and the Sikhs
by Vengrai P. Sarathy on 2009-07-31 03:02:31.238616+05:30 The Censor Board should be able to incorporate members of representative bodies to clear such films and avoid apologies. It looks like all that one has to do is to raise objections as 'offending' some sentiment or other and that becomes a signal for more protests. In this casse the Punjab Cultural Board could have been included by the Board before clearing the movie for release. Vengrai P.Sarathy
Reply | Forward
Aaaj Kal
by Rohit on 2009-07-30 21:27:20.541006+05:30 I am shocked at leaders of our community who make such strong objections to minor things. There is so many other important issues (like poverty, education, Women welfare, child welfare) that needs to be addressed but we tend to focus on minor film issues. Who cares its a film, by no means it represent sikh community world wide. I know lot of sikhs who are very intelligent, hard working and successfull in their lives. People need to move on.
Reply | Forward
Aaaj Kal
by Harinder Singh on 2009-07-30 17:41:45.12911+05:30 Sikh religious body should look after religious matters only and should not comment on length of beard etc. I,however, strongly object to sikhs being presented as bafoons and butt of racial jokes in movies or tv serials.
Reply | Forward
Gurudwara is supposed to be "Community Centre"
by Navjot Parashar on 2009-07-30 16:05:49.965328+05:30 "It's a pitty that beard-man thinks that they are sikh!"I am shocked to read the news about the fuss created for the movie. It seems that "Punjabi-Sardaar" believes that they are the only who are sikhs!"Every Sikh must have a Guru. All the people from Punjab used to visit Gurudwara to resolve their issues and have a public gathering (meetings). Till the time of Guru Arjan Devji, the same purpose was very much served but when the sixth guru militarised the Skhism, it became an army and lost its original touch of accomodating every body.
Reply | Forward
1 You are wrong-Navjot
by ravinder on 2009-07-30 18:05:16.22666+05:30Navjot,you are wrong in saying 'after militirised the sikhism,it became an army
Reply | Forward
1 Get the facts right Navjot
by Sunny on 2009-07-30 19:58:39.886521+05:30Agree with you 100% Ravinder, Novjot please get all the facts and then comment on Sikhism.... Thanks
Reply | Forward
the new taliban?
by shyam on 2009-07-30 15:04:53.047736+05:30 Hullabaloo about beard length? inability to take a joke? banning movies? this seems more the modus operandi of the taliban than of sikhs in inda..i always thought that the sikhs were a tolerant loving people..what happened?shame on saif ali khan for bowing down to these intolerant self appointed moral guardians and allowing his freedom of expression to be curbed.if you dont like whats in the film.... dont watch it!!
Reply | Forward
1 $$$
by Sunny on 2009-07-30 19:55:00.787997+05:30What are you talking about Shyam, all Mr. Khan is trying to do is save his investment, right now his money is invested in this film and he will say sorry to any one and everyone if he has to.... but I do agree with you length of beard is a stupid issue to raise. Also media should stop showing Sikhs like some circus joker and stop these racial jokes.
Reply | Forward
I am prouds of Sikhs.....
by Amit Purohit on 2009-07-30 11:51:48.690169+05:30 I am proud of Sikhhism and Sikhs both.They are jewels of India. Guru Nanak taught the world the forst example on how to sucessfully resist terroism and win over it.I am aware that my current existance has been protected by Sikhs and Rajputs only.Jai GuruNanak,Jai Sikkhism and Jai Hind.
Reply | Forward
1 Comments by Amrit
by J.P.Singh on 2009-07-30 19:00:09.271125+05:30No one is questioning the patriotism or heritage of Sikhs.The objections raised by these self appointed guardians of Sikhism is not acceptable
Reply | Forward